baked oats green chile chicken enchiladas chow mein bakery-style butter cookies

copyright jennifer yu © 2004-2023 all rights reserved: no photos or content may be reproduced without prior written consent

none of that weak sauce

Recipe: homemade pizza sauce

Windstorms in winter accompany large temperature throws in our area. So when we go from single digits to well above freezing in a day, it’s a good idea to secure any outdoor furniture, grills, trampolines, small children, and pets. The winds were quite nasty earlier in the week, but now that the neighbors’ fences have stopped blowing over and the large tree branches are done snapping, we’re back to our normal dose of winds in the 20-40 mph range. It is what it is. As if to apologize for its bad behavior, the atmosphere made nice with the sun Tuesday evening.

cotton candy sunset

I’ve been in cleaning mode lately. That’s what I do when Jeremy is out of town. I start cleaning out closets or reorganizing shelves at night, which produces heaps of donations and recycling. This activity always makes Jeremy a little nervous because I desperately want to clean his mess of a desk, but I usually get too frustrated when I try to figure out where to start. While returning some canning jars to the canning cabinet in the basement, I took inventory of my tomatoes. Tomatoes are what I use the most in the non-summer months – mostly diced tomatoes. When I first began canning, I incorrectly assumed that I used diced tomatoes and tomato sauce at the same rate. By the following summer, my diced tomatoes were nearly finished and my sauce remained untouched. Why not make pizza sauce? Until last year, I bought a pretty spendy pizza sauce from Whole Foods because it wasn’t loaded with sugar and it tasted the best. But then I began searching for a pizza sauce that I could make from my own tomato sauce. Most of the recipes I researched called for diced tomatoes, which didn’t solve my problem, but this one uses tomato sauce – and it is AWESOME.

black pepper, tomato paste, tomato sauce, garlic, brown sugar, red pepper flakes, parmesan, onion, water, olive oil, salt, oregano, basil

dice the onion and mince the garlic

everything measured and prepped

Sure, this pizza sauce isn’t as simple as opening a jar, but it’s straight forward enough that you can make a double or triple batch, fridge or freeze it, and have it ready when you want to whip up some pizza. It involves some knife work (dicing, mincing, and chopping), sauté, and a long simmer. And that’s it! I prefer to use fresh herbs, but dried will work too. A little sugar adds flavor, but you can reduce (or increase) as you see fit. That’s why I like making my own sauce – because I get to control what goes into it. And it’s far far more economical than the spendy (but good!) sauce in a jar.

add minced garlic to the sautéed onions

stir in the herbs and seasonings

add the rest of the ingredients

You can buy tomato sauce if you don’t have your own, or substitute diced tomatoes because it all gets cooked down for at least an hour. I suggest simmering for two hours to reduce the water content and concentrate the flavors. Watery pizza sauce makes my pizza crust soggy. Once the sauce is ready, you can use it immediately or you can store it in a jar with an airtight lid in the refrigerator. Or you can freeze the sauce however you like freezing things. My sauce never makes it past two weeks in the refrigerator because we use it up – so I know it’s good for refrigerated storage up to that point.

simmered down

one batch yielded 2.5 cups of sauce for me

I said earlier that this sauce is awesome. Jeremy raves about it every time we make pizza now. The flavor is most certainly fresher and brighter than any store-bought pizza sauce. I think that has a lot to do with using my tomato sauce made from ripe local summer organic tomatoes – but I’m pretty sure using purchased tomato sauce would still give you a better result than store-bought pizza sauce. I liked that it was thick (by my design) rather than runny. My pizza sauce has chunks of soft onion in it, but if you prefer a smooth sauce, just run that sucker through a blender or food processor (immersion blender is also handy, but potentially messy). It’s just a good feeling to know what is in your food.

spreading sauce on pizza dough

it’s pizza time!

Homemade Pizza Sauce
[print recipe]
from oh, sweet basil

2 tbsps olive oil
1 medium onion, fine dice
4 cloves garlic, minced
1/2 tsp red pepper flakes
2 tsps fresh basil, chopped (or 1 tsp dried basil)
1 tsp fresh oregano, chopped (or 1/2 tsp dried oregano)
16 oz. tomato sauce
4 tbsps tomato paste
5 tbsps Parmesan, grated
2 tsps brown sugar
2/3 cup warm water
salt to taste
pepper to taste

Place the olive oil in a large sauté pan or stock pot over medium heat. When the oil is hot, add the onions and sauté until soft, about 5 minutes. Stir the garlic into the onions. Stir in the red pepper flakes, basil, and oregano. Add the tomato sauce, tomato paste, Parmesan cheese, brown sugar, water, salt, and pepper and stir to combine. Bring the sauce to a boil and reduce to a simmer over low heat for 1 to 2 hours. I simmered for 2 hours and got 2.5 cups of sauce. Can be stored in an airtight jar for up to 2 weeks.

more goodness from the use real butter archives

bolognese sauce butternut squash pasta sauce tomato sauce (canning) red chile (enchilada) sauce

14 nibbles at “none of that weak sauce”

  1. Thekitchwitch says:

    Definitely trying this! I make my own spaghetti sauce but not pizza sauce. I started making my own spaghetti sauce after a jar of the store-bought kind fell out of a grocery bag and exploded on my driveway; it immediately attracted a HORDE of wasps (there was a wasp nest nearby, unbeknownst to me until that moment)! Guess that jarred sauce has so much sugar in it that is is wasp crack. Eek! I was horrified! Now I make my own.

  2. Laura says:

    YUM! I love making my own sauce too. I’m definitely putting this on my list for our next pizza party! :)

  3. Kristin says:

    I make homemade pizza sauce, but this sounds better. Definitely going to try it!

  4. Sharon says:

    Thanks Jen!

  5. Heather says:

    Jen, I’ve been using this recipe for years (minus the tomato paste and a few altered procedures). It’s my go to sauce for pasta and pizza. Last summer, my family canned about 200 cans of crushed tomatoes. To thicken my sauce, I like to dump a can of tomatos onto a sieve and drain a good deal of the tomato juice. Then I’ll use my magic bullet to make the tomatos into a smooth sauce and then simmer with spices and garlic and onions. I normally only simmer for 20 minutes cause it’s already quite thick and cause I’m too lazy to do it for 1-2 hours…

  6. Jan says:

    Honestly have never purchased pizza sauce; always made it. My recipe is not as complex as yours and has no cheese in it, but that would really add a nice dimension. It sounds really delicious!

  7. Ellen says:

    This recipe sounds so delicious and much better than the bottle jars I buy! Can’t wait to make this while the football games are on this weekend! I’ve never made my own pizza sauce and can’t wait to start! Thank you for sharing!

  8. Pey-Lih says:

    Here! Here! I am all for a strong sauce on my pizza! Strong winds? It’s grey and overcast here along the southern coast this morning. I like the idea of cleaning out and reorganizing. This is what I plan on doing over the weekend with a less hectic course schedule this semester. I going to keep my promise to find balance this year.

  9. Culinare says:

    In my family pizza is the first favorite dish. My little girls would eat all day. Thanks for this recipe.

  10. jenyu says:

    TKW – oh yes, homemade never explodes in driveways or brings a swarm of wasps! And it’s ridiculous how much sugar is in store-bought sauces.

    Laura – :)

    Kristin – I hope you like it! We love it.

    Sharon – xo

    Heather – 200 cans of crushed tomatoes? I wish you were my neighbor :)

    Jan – yes, it’s great! I think there is great flexibility in making your own sauce – which is what I love about it!

    Ellen – you’re so welcome!

    Pey-Lih – good for you.

    Culinare – :) yay!!

  11. toni says:

    This looks AWESOME!!! Thank you for sharing your recipe. :)

  12. Kimberly L. says:

    Goodness, that is a huge jar of tomato paste. I tend to buy those tiny cans and never seem to finish it before it goes to waste. Just curious, but do you have a secret for storing it that I should be aware of? Or do you just using that much paste regularly?

  13. jenyu says:

    Kimberly – I freeze any unused tomato paste in tablespoon batches.

  14. Rika says:

    I made this recipe to go with my sourdough pizza crust experiment. Luckily, they were both a hit with a visiting friend. I’ve made a few pizza sauce recipes over the years (and bought more than a few jars of the stuff) and I have to say, this is my new fave. Thanks!

leave a reply