baked oats green chile chicken enchiladas chow mein bakery-style butter cookies

copyright jennifer yu © 2004-2023 all rights reserved: no photos or content may be reproduced without prior written consent

when holidays attack

Recipe: eggnog ice cream

The past week was supposed to go something like this: big cold front with lots of snow, frigid subzero temperatures for several days, then a warm front ushered in by the obligatory wind storms. All of that happened with the exception of “lots of snow”. We got some snow, but nothing close to a Big Dump Snow Day. Kaweah certainly enjoyed it, until it was a bit much for even this cold-loving dog. Taking her out for a walk ended up with me carrying her back to the house because her paws would freeze in the -3°F temperatures. Kaweah would lift one paw in pain and then lift the other, totally confused until I picked her up in my arms and began walking home. She likes getting the view from up high and wags her tail while I tell her it’s just too cold of a day for a puppy like her.

before the frigid temperatures and crazy winds arrived

But Jeremy and I are good to 0°F or lower as long as it isn’t windy. Problem with Nederland is that it is ALWAYS windy. That’s why this cold spell was so peculiar – it sat over Colorado for several days and the air was completely still. Snow remained on trees for a week (unheard of!) and the trails were snow covered instead of wind blasted down to the rocks. Cold is cold, but windless is priceless. You have to take advantage when you can.

backcountry touring

testing my new microspikes (excellent!) and my midweight running tights (also excellent!)

nice teeth for traction (not great in deep powder)

Everything else has been a mad scramble for holiday-related deadlines. As some of you know, we don’t do the holidays. However, I *do* bake a metric boat load of cookies to gift. This involves stocking up on a lot of butter (natch), sugar, flour, eggs, chocolate, powdered sugar, nuts, and other cookie-ish ingredients. Running errands in town coincides with the holiday crush on the roads, in the stores… It’s a bit much for me and it’s stressful. So I decided to relax with some eggnog. Except I forgot to buy some at the store because I had to wait a long time for the staff person to come back and tell me they were cleaned out of pistachios and then my brain had to recalculate my baking schedule and ingredients list. Once home, I went poking around on the interwebs and discovered I had everything I needed to make my own eggnog. And then came the brilliant idea of eggnog ice cream.

egg yolks, vanilla bean, milk, cream, salt, sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, rum, vanilla extract

scrape the seeds from the pod

combine the vanilla bean, vanilla seeds, cinnamon, nutmeg, salt, milk, and half of the cream

My friend, Kathya, was asking folks on Facebook how they felt about eggnog. I mentioned that I had just made this ice cream. She asked when I would post it, so I’m posting it now – for Kathya and the rest of you eggnog ice cream lovers. And if you dislike eggnog for the consistency, let me just state that eggnog in frozen creamy form is pretty spanking awesome. It’s also easy peasy to make.

stir in the sugar

temper the yolks with some hot milk-cream mixture

pour the tempered egg mixture back into the pan

The original eggnog ice cream recipe came from one of my favorite and most trusted sites, Simply Recipes. I altered it ever so slightly by adding a vanilla bean, because it really lends to the sweet and warm floral flavors that play so nicely with the spices. Also? I like creamy things with booze. They just go so well together. So this recipe is all winner! winner! ice cream for dinner!

strain the custard into a bowl with the remaining cream

pour the booze of your choosing into the custard

and the vanilla extract (i use both the vanilla bean and extract)

When you taste the custard before it is churned, it’s very much like eggnog – just thicker and creamier. I must say that turning it into ice cream transforms it completely. Even for an eggnog lover such as myself, the eggnog ice cream is ten times better than the eggnog beverage. It’s like a spiced and boozy high quality vanilla bean ice cream.

pour the chilled custard into the ice cream maker

soft serve

Jeremy is no fan of eggnog. He won’t touch the stuff… makes a face if you even bring it near him. I offered a spoonful of eggnog ice cream for him to try and now he’s hooked. So if someone tells you they hate eggnog and it’s because of the consistency of the drink, consider serving them some eggnog ice cream. It’s festive and holiday-appropriate, but most of all it is fan-freaking-tastic.

the solid phase of eggnog is the best phase

Eggnog Ice Cream
[print recipe]
from Simply Recipes

2 cups heavy cream
1 cup milk
1 vanilla bean, split and seeds scraped
4 whole cloves
1 tsp grated nutmeg (freshly grated is best)
1/4 tsp ground cinnamon
pinch salt
2/3 cup sugar
6 egg yolks
1 tsp vanilla extract
2 tbsps rum, bourbon, or brandy

Place 1 cup of the cream, the milk, the vanilla bean pod and seeds, nutmeg, cinnamon, and salt into a medium saucepan. Heat the milk and cream until steaming, but not yet boiling. Remove from heat. Stir in the sugar until dissolved. Cover with a tight-fitting lid and let steep for 30 minutes. Remove the vanilla bean pod and the cloves. Pour the remaining cup of cream into a large bowl with a sieve set over it. In a medium bowl, whisk the egg yolks to break them up. Ladle 1/2 cup of the hot milk-cream into the yolks until blended. Repeat with another 1/2 cup of the milk-cream. Scrape the egg yolk mixture into the saucepan with the hot milk-cream, stirring to incorporate. Set the pan over medium heat, stirring constantly and scraping the bottom until the custard thickens to a nappe consistency (coats the back of spoon and leaves a strip when you run your finger across the spoon). Strain the custard into the cream in the large bowl. Stir in the vanilla extract and the rum (or bourbon or brandy). Chill the custard completely. Churn chilled custard in your ice cream machine according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Makes a quart.

more goodness from the use real butter archives

rum raisin ice cream pistachio ice cream key lime pie ice cream peppermint ice cream

14 nibbles at “when holidays attack”

  1. Kristin says:

    My family loves ice cream and eggnog, so we will have to try this one over the holidays. Maybe I’ll serve it with the half of your excellent chocolate bourbon cake that is in the freezer. Yum!

  2. Laurel says:

    Ah yes the puppy-paws-in-the-air dance when it is too cold. We found that the Pawz booties worked great because they kept the snow out from between my pup’s toes so she could still frolic in the cold. (Although of course there will be a limit to just how cold any pup can be expected enjoy!)

  3. Trolleira says:

    I think, this is the only way to have eggnog for christmas here in Brazil in this blasting heat! Great idea!!!

  4. Broken Nose Vanilla says:

    How could Broken Nose Vanilla NOT like something that has both vanilla bean AND vanilla extract! Thanks, Jen, for once again indulging my new addition: your wonderful recipes, photos and commentary.

  5. Sophie says:

    Oh, I want this! I am an eggnog lover, but it is terribly sweet and rich so I usually just put a little in my coffee in place of cream. I LOVE eggnog ice cream and sometimes can’t find any proper types in the store…. this is SUCH a better idea! Love love love. This would go well as dessert after my favorite eggnog pancakes :) Hahaha. But seriously.

  6. Anita says:

    Wah, I love eggnog! And this being 10 times better than liquid eggnog, gah, I am drooling right now. Would have gone straight to making some of this if I have an ice cream machine. Maybe I will still go ahead and do it, and just enjoy it in liquid phase :)

  7. Judy says:

    I had that with my dog but the opposite. His paws got burned on the pavement. And I wouldn’t have been able to carry him.
    I take it you’ve recently had a birthday. Many happy returns of the day.

  8. Judy says:

    I’ve just read the doggy bloggy. It was lovely.
    December 2011 you made me cry.
    I was looking in the chefs site. What lovely things are there. I wouldn’t say no to a $100 voucher for there if I lived in America.
    Merry Christmas. Do you do Christmas?

  9. Michelle says:

    The sugar is not in the instruction part of the recipe (but is in the ingredient list and photos). The custard smells fantastic! Can’t wait to churn it tomorrow!

  10. jenyu says:

    Michelle – you are right. Thank you for catching that – I’ll fix it now!

  11. What’s Cookin’? The Christmas Edition | says:

    […] Eggnog Ice Cream from Use Real Butter […]

  12. jenyu says:

    Kristin – ahhh, cake and ice cream are a match made in heaven!

    Laurel – We use PAWZ indoors on the hardwood floors for Kaweah’s traction. Those things are such a life saver!

    Trolleira – ah yes, you are so right!! Refreshing, to say the least!

    Broken Nose Vanilla – thank you!

    Sophie – wow, eggnog pancakes? I gotta try that :)

    Anita – I think the liquid phase recipe has the milk and cream proportions reversed (more milk, less cream). But the ice cream version is totally worth getting a $40 ice cream maker! Just saying… ;)

    Judy – awwww, poor baby! Kaweah had a birthday (on the 14th). And yes, puppy paws can be sensitive to heat and cold! We don’t celebrate Christmas, but I do distribute a lot of holiday cookies :)

  13. A_Boleyn says:

    The 4 cloves are also not mentioned as being added along with the vanilla pod, seeds etc but you do mention fishing them out later.

    I made the ice cream this evening and it’s hardening in the freezer for tomorrow’s taste test … though the remnants on the ice cream paddle, in the freezer canister etc were pretty good, just not enough to make a definitive judgement. :)

  14. jenyu says:

    A_Boleyn – thanks for that! I fixed it :)

leave a reply