baked oats green chile chicken enchiladas chow mein bakery-style butter cookies

copyright jennifer yu © 2004-2023 all rights reserved: no photos or content may be reproduced without prior written consent

pot pie season

Recipe: pheasant chanterelle pot pie

Colorado has been sitting under a trough (low pressure) of late that has delivered rain, fog, cold, and even snow in the higher elevations. I’ve been casually catching fall colors when I can, but mostly I made a point of enjoying them rather than trying to make photos. I mean, you can always take iPhone snaps, which is mostly what I do these days, but you can also dedicate time, energy, and effort in making some exceptional images. A pretty hectic summer left me burned out when the fall colors came around, such that I couldn’t see myself doing the fall shoot well and then diving into my first hunting season. So I gave myself some time off from the shoot to catch up on a lot of work, do some much-needed research, and take care of things at home.

flaming and gorgeous

i love to stand in the stands

jeremy and neva checking out the local aspens

Something Jeremy and I let slide this summer was Neva’s training. We spent a good bit of time training her to swim between our paddleboards or run alongside the bike, but we stopped working with the e-collar which our trainer had taught us to use back in March. There had been a bad episode in the spring that pretty much left me in tears (Neva seemed to be fine after 5 seconds). Neva had bolted out of sight on the soccer field and it was so windy we couldn’t hear anything as we ran after her. I used the collar, but couldn’t see or hear any feedback, so I boosted the stimulation and tapped it again until I was on the next field and saw her leaning up against Jeremy for comforting. Apparently, Jeremy saw her stop after one of the zaps and she turned to run back to him. As she ran to him, I was still coming around the other side of the field and couldn’t see her and did a boost and tap which made her cry out and jump. The whole thing made me want to throw the e-collar away forever. I silently wiped away tears the whole walk home because Jeremy said we should act as if everything is normal so as not to alarm her. I later consulted with Claire, got reassurances and advice for the future, and promptly stopped using the e-collar. I hated that I had hurt my baby dog.

But we decided to try it again this weekend with leash work and you know what? Neva was wonderful. We hardly needed to use the collar (and at very very low levels) and she was so responsive and happy on her hikes despite encountering lots of other hikers including children (little people are particularly exciting because they are at eye level), two moose, other dogs (who were not well-behaved at all), and runners. She trotted alongside Jeremy, looking up to him every few seconds, tail wagging, a slack leash, and slowing herself down when he said, “whoa” or “heel” or “no pull”. I don’t feel Neva ever needs to be off leash in our big wide wildernesses, but if she can be on leash and enjoy her time outside as a good girl, that’s all we ever really wanted. So that was huge progress.

another aspen stand with a good neva

look at that slack leash!

I’ve been in fall cleaning mode because somehow I am always six months late tackling spring cleaning. The chest freezer was in need of attention because it was packed to the gills with vodka infusions, freezer jams, meats, mushrooms, fruit, nuts, ice creams, butter, homemade broth, green chiles. Things get lost in there and don’t emerge until four years later when you are trying to find a place to store your 2017 huckleberries. It was time to start making room by eating stuff. One of my Crested Butte neighbors likes to hunt pheasant. I think he likes hunting them more than eating them, so when he learned that I LOVE pheasant, he pulled one out of their freezer this summer and gave it to me! I knew just the thing to make… a pot pie with some of my foraged wild mushrooms.

chanterelles from august

cleaned and sliced

sauté with some butter

ready to freeze or eat

There wasn’t time to make and shoot the recipe until last week when it coincidentally cooled off by a good 20 degrees. That’s why I butter sautéed my chanterelles in August and chucked them into the freezer for a month until I could get around to using them. My preference would have been to roast the pheasant and shred the meat for the pot pie filling, but 1) it didn’t have any skin and 2) there was buck shot scattered throughout. This is only my second pheasant I’ve prepared, but I feel more comfortable dicing the meat so I can remove any shot and feathers. I used all of the meat I could and then froze the carcass to make pheasant broth later because it’s delicious and because I hate wasting food. The pheasant broth in this pie is from the previous pheasant carcass.

the filling: potatoes, lima beans, salt, bay leaves, butter, pheasant, pepper, chanterelles, onion, flour, more butter, pheasant broth

diced and prepped

simmer the potatoes in the broth with the bay leaves

strain out the potatoes and reduce the broth

I realize not everyone has access to pheasant, in which case you can use any game bird or poultry in its place. It’s a pretty lean meat, so I sauté it in butter until the outside is cooked, but the inside is still pink. This helps to keep it tender when it finishes baking in the pie.

season the pheasant with salt and pepper

cook until pink inside

sauté the onions

When all of the ingredients are ready, make the gravy. I don’t cook the frozen lima beans because they come already cooked. The reduced broth should be warmed before you add it to the roux. It just keeps the temperature from dropping as you make the gravy sauce. When it’s all done, mix everything together. That’s your pot pie filling. I split up the process of making the pie over three days. This was day one. The filling will keep in the refrigerator for 3 or so days. It is also absolutely delicious to spoon straight into your mouth.

stir flour into hot butter to make a roux

whisk the reduced broth into the roux a little at a time (on the stove) until thickened

season the gravy

add the other filling ingredients to the pan

stir it all together

On the second day, I made the pie dough. I have not had great experiences with pie dough until recently. A few readers had pointed me to Kenji’s pie crust dough recipe over at The Food Lab and I finally gave it a try. It works for me and I freaking love it. Thank you, readers. I love you guys. I reduced the amount of sugar in the pie dough for this savory pie, but some sugar is still good for browning in the crust.

butter, flour, cold water, salt, sugar

pulse the butter, some of the flour, sugar, and salt together until it clumps

cut in the rest of the flour

place the dough in a bowl and sprinkle water over it

fold the water into the dough

make two discs and refrigerate

If you can only spend a little time here and there on a recipe, I get it. The dough takes about ten minutes tops to put together and then you can wrap it and pop it into the refrigerator for up to three days or the freezer for up to 3 months. Nice. Now on to assembly.

roll out the dough discs

line a pie dish with dough, then fill with the filling

place the top crust over the filling and seal, trim, and crimp

I had about a cup of leftover filling which Jeremy took for lunch one day (he said it was delicious). You could also make a smaller pie with the leftovers or try to stuff it all into the pie. I got a little nervous as my pie was quite full and I didn’t want to risk anything since I only had the one pheasant. On this pie, I made the mistake of putting foil around the edges at the beginning to prevent burning. I didn’t realize that the pie dough would stick to the foil and come off when I removed the foil. Sorry, I’m not an experienced pie baker. Except I kinda am, now. I’ve baked four pies in the last two weeks and I find it best to bake the pie for about 40 minutes and when the edges are just right, cover them with foil and let the center continue to brown. That works much better, you only need to take care not to burn yourself or crush the pie crust when you place the foil guard. I find it helps tremendously to pleat the top edge of each foil strip so it curves naturally.

egg wash: egg and cream

whisk the egg and cream together

brush the pie crust with egg wash

cut some steam vents

bake until golden


This pie is so damn good. I have rather mixed feelings about chicken – I think the flavor is pretty neutral, which might explain why I love game birds. Pheasant is sweet and flavorful and delicious. I don’t find it gamey at all. The pieces remained tender in the pie and complemented the chanterelles nicely. I like the idea of pairing wild foods that have similar seasons. I worried that the pheasant broth would be too weak in flavor, but once it was reduced, it held up well with all of the vegetables and mushrooms and pheasant. Wrap that in a flaky, buttery pie crust and you have yourself a winner.

savory perfection

a loving slice

loaded with good and wild things

Pheasant Chanterelle Pot Pie
[print recipe]
based on this recipe from Saveur

pie crust dough
adjusted from The Food Lab
2 1/2 cups (350g or 12.5 oz) all-purpose flour
1 tbsp (12g) granulated sugar
1 tsp (5g) kosher salt
10 oz. (20 tbsps) unsalted butter, cold and cut into 1/4-inch cubes
6 tbsps ice cold water

Place 1 1/2 cups of flour, the sugar, and salt into the bowl of a food processor. Pulse 5 times to combine. Distribute the butter over the flour mixture in the food processor. Pulse until the dough clumps (I pulsed about 25 times and then ran it 15 seconds at a time until it clumped). Sprinkle the rest of the flour over the dough and cut it into the dough by pulsing about 5-10 times until the dough has broken into small chunks. Empty the dough into a large bowl and sprinkle the cold water over the dough. Fold the water into the dough with a soft spatula (don’t use your hands, the heat will melt the butter). All of the loose crumbs will come together into a ball. Cut the dough into two halves and shape them into 4-inch diameter discs. Wrap each disc in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least two hours or up to three days. If not using within three days, freeze the dough for up to 3 months.

4 cups pheasant broth* or chicken broth
2 bay leaves
2 yukon gold potatoes, large dice (about 2 cups)
8 oz. (about 1 1/2 cups) fresh chanterelles, cut in half or quarters if they are large
5 tbsps unsalted butter
sea salt
1 lb. pheasant meat, 1-inch dice
freshly ground black pepper
1 tbsp vegetable oil
1 medium onion, diced
3 tbsps all-purpose flour
1 cup baby lima beans

1 egg, beaten (for egg wash)
1 tbsp cream

*I made pheasant stock from another pheasant carcass I had in the freezer. I basically covered it with water in a pressure cooker and set it on high for 15 minutes then natural release.

Cook the potatoes and reduce the broth: Bring the broth and the bay leaves to a boil in a medium saucepan. Reduce the heat to medium or medium low heat and add the potatoes. Cook the potatoes until tender (about 10 minutes). Remove the potatoes with a slotted spoon to a large bowl. Simmer the broth until it has reduced to about 2 cups. Discard the bay leaves and set the broth aside.

Sauté the mushrooms, pheasant, and onions: Melt a tablespoon of butter in a sauté pan over medium high heat. Add the chanterelles to the pan when the butter begins to bubble. Sauté until the mushrooms wilt. Sprinkle a pinch of salt over the mushrooms. When they are cooked, remove them from the pan to the bowl with the potatoes.

Season the pheasant with salt and pepper (about 1/2 tsp each) and mix to distribute. Using the same sauté pan, melt a tablespoon of butter in the pan over medium high heat. When the butter begins to sizzle, add the pheasant and sauté until the outsides are cooked (leave it pink in the center). Remove from heat and add the pheasant to the large bowl.

Using the same sauté pan, heat the vegetable oil over medium high heat. When the oil is hot, sauté the onions until translucent. Add the onions to the large bowl.

Make the roux and combine the filling: If the broth has cooled, reheat it while you prepare the roux. Using the same sauté pan, melt the remaining 3 tablespoons of butter over medium high heat. Stir the flour into the butter and keep stirring until the roux turns brown. Ladle a little bit of the hot broth into the roux at a time while whisking to incorporate it. Keep adding more broth while whisking until you get a thickened gravy (about 10 minutes). Season with salt and pepper. Add the potatoes, mushrooms, pheasant, onions, and lima beans into the gravy and stir to combine. At this point you can let the filling cool and refrigerate it for up to 3 days before using.

Assemble and bake the pie: Preheat oven to 375°F with rack in the center of the oven. Roll the two dough discs out to 1/4-inch thickness. Line a 9-inch pie dish with the larger of the two pie crusts, pressing the dough into the corners. Pour the filling into the pie dish (you may have leftover filling – that’s okay, it’s great to eat on its own). Cover the pie with the other pie crust dough and seal, trim, and crimp the edges together. Whisk the egg and cream together. Brush egg wash over the pie crust and cut steam vents in the top to allow steam to escape during baking. Bake for an hour. If the edges of the pie crust brown faster than the center, you can cover the edges with foil after about 40 minutes. I tried doing it before the pie went into the oven, but the dough winds up sticking to the foil – so covering it after it has browned works better, you just have to be careful about not burning yourself. Remove the pie from the oven and let it rest for 15 minutes before serving. Serves 6-8.

more goodness from the use real butter archives

pheasant and morel vols au vent chanterelle mushroom hand pies chicken pot hand pies beef porcini pot pies

7 nibbles at “pot pie season”

  1. Ellie's friend from Canada says:

    This sounds like a truly delicious recipe. I love your fall foliage photos too and it’s nice to hear the Neva is
    learning everything, too. On your way to a calmer canine companion! It is good that you keep her on a leash in the woods. Here it is illegal to have a dog off leash in a national or provincial park. One reason is you don’t want your dog charging into the woods and being chased out by a bear, the dog leading the bear right to you!

    I am getting organized to try some of your lovely recipes. Thanks


  2. Melissa says:

    Aww Neva. :\ I’m glad you (and she) were able to give it another try though. Good girl.

    Great use of the pheasant. I took apart three this year (all gifts) and the first one was definitely a little rough on me, trying to cut away the meat and get the scattered metal out. But as with anything in the kitchen, I continue to get better at it with more practice. I’m hoping for more gifting this next year. :)

  3. Sarah says:

    Wow this looks delicious! And your fall photos make me want to take a trip to Colorado.

    I love reading your blog regularly but have never posted before. However after reading your latest training session with Neva I had to share because I can totally relate. I have two dogs and one is a big-time puller who absolutely must sniff/chase/investigate everything! We tried everything to teach him loose leash walking including clicker training, group classes, personal training in our home, etc. After a year or two, we finally just gave up honestly and dealt with the pulling hoping he’d eventually grow out of it. Then one day when he was about 3, and we were at the pet store packing up on treats and supplies for a week vacation (with the dogs of course), we decided to buy one of those no-pull harnesses (the kind that goes around the chest not the nose) on a whim in hopes we could have a more relaxing vacation given all the hikes we had planned. It has been a complete and total game-changer. I would say pulling was immediately reduced by 75%. And as far as I can tell, it doesn’t hurt him any more than a typical collar does when he does pull. Anyway just wanted to share in case you haven’t tried it before, its the only thing that made walks more enjoyable for us and I still can’t believe we didn’t try it sooner.

    Love your blog – thanks for sharing so many delicious recipes!

  4. Jill Hyde says:

    I can only imagine your fear when you couldn’t find your Neva girl. Sounds like training has been a huge success with her! I’m sorry about your experience with the collar.
    Beautiful blog, your crust is so sweet. xoxo, j

  5. Shari Q says:

    I LOVE PHEASANT!!! I don’t have a dog so hunting is out :-( I so miss this wonderful tasting bird. Where did you get your pheasant?

  6. jenyu says:

    Ann – Yes, we feel strongly that dogs should not be allowed to harass the wildlife. I’m not too concerned about dealing with large wildlife (we deal with them a lot and safely), but a dog on the loose can really stress out these animals. Many dog owners think their dogs are “just having fun”, but their fun is terrorizing the local fauna, which I think is cruel. xo

    Melissa – We’re both (or all three) learning. All I want is for her to be happy without making Jeremy crazy ;) As for the pheasant, I TOTALLY know what you mean. But it’s good practice because I’m hoping to get some grouse this fall. That’s one of the reasons I went with an air rifle and grouse, because it won’t mess up the body like a shot gun and these guys don’t really fly much. Do you guys have opportunity to hunt pheasant around there? I think the shotgun thing is what turns me off from hunting pheasant (the shot gets everywhere). Friending pheasant hunters is probably my best option. Some folks don’t even like to eat them, they just like hunting them. Uh – pass your birds over here, please! :)

    Sarah – Thanks for sharing your experience! We have so much hardware for Neva we could almost open a store. We use a combination of the harness and the halti collar with Neva. She pulls less but still pulls A LOT. The halti (gentle leader) seemed to be the most effective without the use of the e-collar, but she hates it and tries to rub it off on your legs at every opportunity. The harness doesn’t bother her, but she also pulls more with just the harness on, which leads to rubbing her hair off and leaving a few scabs on her chest. I hate that. With the e-collar, we can walk her on her regular old flat collar and she’s 1) well-behaved and 2) happy! :) I think it’s a matter of finding what works best for your pup. Each dog is different. I’m glad you found a solution!

    Jill – Thank you. It was harder on me than on Neva, but we learn and that’s how we grow <3 xo

    Shari - Ha ha! I have a dog and I still don't hunt pheasant ;) My pheasant came from neighbors who hunt. But I think there are places online where you can order frozen pheasant!

  7. Melissa says:

    That’s awesome about the grouse – I wish you many happy returns. I’ve actually been offered the opportunity to go pheasant hunting, but honestly both Steve and I don’t have much interest in the process of bird hunting. Seems odd considering. But for now we will stick to bowhunting (and sometimes rifle hunting) deer and pig. I am just thankful my pheasant-hunting coworker loves to share!

leave a reply